Index funds vs stock picking: what is the real difference?
A plain explanation of what an index fund is, what stock picking asks of you, and the trade-offs between them.
"Should I buy an index fund or pick my own stocks?" is a common question for new investors. This post explains both approaches, how they differ in cost and risk and what the evidence says, without telling you what to do. All investments can lose value, you may get back less than you put in and past performance does not predict the future. The money examples use invented figures without a currency, so they apply anywhere.
What an index fund is
A stock market index is a list of companies with a rule for including them and weighting them. A well-known example is an index of the largest companies in a country. An index fund (or index-tracking ETF) simply holds the companies in that list in the same proportions, so its result closely follows the index minus costs. Nobody is choosing which companies look best; the rule decides. That is why it is called passive investing. A single fund can hold hundreds or thousands of companies, which is what spreads your risk across many of them.
What stock picking is
Stock picking means choosing individual companies, because you believe they will do better than the market. Active funds do the same with professional managers. Your result then depends on the companies you chose. You might do much better than an index, much worse, or about the same, and you will not know which in advance.
The three differences that matter
1. Diversification
If you hold one company and it fails, you lose most of that money. If you hold a broad index fund of 1,000 companies and one fails, you barely notice. Owning a handful of stocks is a concentrated bet. Concentration can pay off, but it is also how large losses happen. A rule of thumb many guides give is that individual shares should be a small part of a portfolio, but it is only a rule of thumb.
2. Cost
Funds charge a yearly percentage, often shown as an ongoing charges figure. Index funds tend to charge less than active funds because they do not pay a team to research companies. Here is why small percentages matter, with invented numbers: 10,000 growing at an assumed 5% a year for 30 years becomes about 43,200. At a 1.5% yearly cost, the net rate is roughly 3.5% and the same 10,000 would be about 28,100. The difference of around 15,000 is paid to costs. It is an illustration with an assumed rate, not a prediction, and you should check the actual fees on any product.
3. Time and attention
Picking stocks means reading company reports, deciding when to buy and sell, and dealing with the feelings when a holding falls. An index fund can be bought once and added to regularly. Some people enjoy research, and some do it as a hobby with a small slice of their money.
What the evidence says
Many studies have compared active managers with their benchmark indexes, and the repeated finding is that a majority of active funds lag their benchmark over long periods after costs. S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes a regular report on this called SPIVA, and you can read it yourself rather than rely on a summary here. A few managers do beat the market for a while, but it is hard to know in advance which. This does not prove an index fund is right for you; it means beating the market consistently is hard even for professionals.
What index funds do not do
- They do not remove risk. If the whole market falls 30%, an index fund falls with it.
- They are not all the same. A global index and a single-country index behave very differently, and so do those that hold only one sector.
- They do not choose how much you should invest, or when you will need the money.
- Costs differ between funds that track the same index; compare them.
Where picking can make sense
Some people hold a core of broad funds and a small amount in individual shares they have researched, for interest or because they know an industry well. The key is knowing what you are doing and limiting the amount so a mistake does not hurt much. Treat this as a hobby budget unless you have experience.
What is in an index, and what is not
A fund that tracks a market-weighted index holds more of the biggest companies, so a few large firms can make up a big share of it. That is a reason to look at what a fund actually holds rather than assuming the name tells you. Some indexes are weighted equally, some by other rules, and each has different strengths and risks. Reading the fund's factsheet, which shows its largest holdings, its costs and the index it tracks, takes only a few minutes.
Index funds and ETFs: is there a difference?
An ETF is a fund that trades on an exchange like a share, and many ETFs track indexes. Traditional index funds are bought and sold directly from the fund company at a daily price. For a long-term investor, the more important differences are fees, what the fund holds and how it is taxed in your country, not the label.
Common mistakes
- Buying a "hot" stock because of social media.
- Holding too few stocks and assuming the portfolio is diversified.
- Judging a fund by last year's return.
- Ignoring fees and tax rules for your country and account type.
- Selling after a fall and missing the recovery.
A few questions to ask before you choose
- What is this money for, and when will I need it?
- Can I cope if it halves for a while?
- What does it cost each year, in total?
- What is in it, and is it overlapping with what I already own?
Seeing what you own
Whichever route you take, it helps to see what you actually hold. Vartu works out average cost, realised and unrealised gain, dividends and a money-weighted return against an index, and it can look through funds to show what is inside them. It also has a target allocation and rebalancing view. Trading 212 and Interactive Brokers statements import directly, and your data stays on your iPhone. One broker account is free. See App Store. To see how growth builds over time, read Compound interest explained with a worked example.
Related calculators
- Compound interest calculator: how much could your investment grow?
- Stock market recovery calculator: what gain do you need after a fall?
On a computer?
Scan with your iPhone camera to open Vartu in the App Store.
More from the blog
- The 50/30/20 rule, and why UK rent can break it
- Compound interest explained with a worked example
- Overpay your mortgage or invest? How to think about the trade-off
- What does 5 April actually mean for your money?
Vartu is not financial advice. Forecasts and estimates are arithmetic on your own figures.